Thread: Make XP for stuns and Kills the same

Make XP for stuns and Kills the same

  1. #1

    Make XP for stuns and Kills the same

    My personal gripe with HR was that a kill would give XP depending on certain factors. I would move that all kills/stuns give the same amount of XP no matter what, because if you want to do a guns blazing run you are only getting 10 xp per kill, but if you do a stun and stealth run you are getting significantly more due to bonuses. For a game that encourages you to "play your way", it should be careful not to give a level progression disadvantage. Getting rid of bonuses and making every stun or kill, no matter how impressive, 10 xp would be a smart move for the sake of overall balance in all playstyles to be cleaner.

    Then all you would need to do is balance the numbers of how much xp it takes to level, then find a way for Pacificst players to gain XP at a faster rate then they usually would as well.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Posts
    1,497
    Originally Posted by Torkegamer
    My personal gripe with HR was that a kill would give XP depending on certain factors. I would move that all kills/stuns give the same amount of XP no matter what, because if you want to do a guns blazing run you are only getting 10 xp per kill, but if you do a stun and stealth run you are getting significantly more due to bonuses. For a game that encourages you to "play your way", it should be careful not to give a level progression disadvantage. Getting rid of bonuses and making every stun or kill, no matter how impressive, 10 xp would be a smart move for the sake of overall balance in all playstyles to be cleaner.

    Then all you would need to do is balance the numbers of how much xp it takes to level, then find a way for Pacificst players to gain XP at a faster rate then they usually would as well.
    Give XP for objectives. There, solved the problem

  3. #3
    Originally Posted by 68_pie
    Give XP for objectives. There, solved the problem
    Yep. Ideally they'll remove XP for killing/stunning enemies. Have your objectives, side objectives and exploration give XP. This would remove any XP need to play a certain way. A side effect is that they can more easily balance the total number of XP in the game and thus how many augs one can unlock at the end. This should make sure we aren't able to unlock everything by the end of the game.
    Rule 30: A little trust goes a long way. The less you use, the further you'll go.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Posts
    1,497
    Originally Posted by Irate_Iguana
    Yep. Ideally they'll remove XP for killing/stunning enemies. Have your objectives, side objectives and exploration give XP. This would remove any XP need to play a certain way. A side effect is that they can more easily balance the total number of XP in the game and thus how many augs one can unlock at the end. This should make sure we aren't able to unlock everything by the end of the game.
    They need to do a better job on the exploration XP as well.

  5. #5
    Originally Posted by 68_pie
    They need to do a better job on the exploration XP as well.
    Not just on the XP reward for exploration. They should have more to explore.
    Rule 30: A little trust goes a long way. The less you use, the further you'll go.

  6. #6
    Originally Posted by Irate_Iguana
    Not just on the XP reward for exploration. They should have more to explore.
    I would argue that what 68_pie said is the best way to go about it. Giving XP for KEY objectives, the objectives every player will accomplish by way of simply finishing a main mission or quest, is a guaranteed way that all players are on the same level at any point in the game regardless of playstyle. Giving XP for exploring would be nice, but exploring in a Dues Ex game is about what you find, whether that's resources or alternative paths, not the XP you get for doing so.

    My only concern for what 68_pie said is that if there are really no other ways to get XP, then balance becomes a huge issue, both in terms of balancing difficulty for each playstyle, and in terms of giving appropriate amounts of XP. Because if some players are having a real big issue getting through the next segment of the game after they were just given some XP and they won't be able to get any more until they either A) finish the current mission or B) go do a sidequest. They may get frustrated with the fact that leveling up is a once every couple hours process.

  7. #7
    Originally Posted by Torkegamer
    exploring in a Dues Ex game is about what you find, whether that's resources or alternative paths, not the XP you get for doing so.
    It's about both. Even the first Deus Ex rewarded you XP for exploring. It was one of the few things it gave XP for other than mission objectives. Human Revolution just didn't have enough to explore for this to be a meaningful addition so we got XP tied to kills and takedowns, and boring 100 XP bonuses for crawling through a specific point in a vent from either direction.
    Speed up the accelerating returns, 'cause carbon doesn’t work, I want to evolve and operate at terahertz.

  8. #8
    Just remove the XP for killing takedowns and hacking ,remove this status bar .If you won't do this then some modder will have to fix this.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Posts
    1,497
    Originally Posted by Torkegamer
    My only concern for what 68_pie said is that if there are really no other ways to get XP, then balance becomes a huge issue, both in terms of balancing difficulty for each playstyle, and in terms of giving appropriate amounts of XP. Because if some players are having a real big issue getting through the next segment of the game after they were just given some XP and they won't be able to get any more until they either A) finish the current mission or B) go do a sidequest. They may get frustrated with the fact that leveling up is a once every couple hours process.
    No. It would make it much easier to balance the game.

    Originally Posted by Shralla
    It's about both. Even the first Deus Ex rewarded you XP for exploring. It was one of the few things it gave XP for other than mission objectives. Human Revolution just didn't have enough to explore for this to be a meaningful addition so we got XP tied to kills and takedowns, and boring 100 XP bonuses for crawling through a specific point in a vent from either direction.
    This basically. You can have small XP exploration bonuses but only for things that are actually a challenge to find.

  10. #10
    Originally Posted by Irate_Iguana
    Not just on the XP reward for exploration. They should have more to explore.
    Personally I think this is what made Deus Ex 1 so amazing. Lots of exploration

Tags for this Thread