Page 1 of 13 1234511 ... Last

Thread: Collecting Reviews HERE

Collecting Reviews HERE

  1. #1

    Collecting Reviews HERE

    Well many Review-Threads so far so here's the list:

    English/Australian mags:
    Games Master UK 96%
    Playstation Official Magazine UK 9/10
    PlayStation Beyond 90%
    Total Film 5/5 -> 100%
    Game Informer 95%
    PTOM 5/5
    Focus 5/5
    Xbox World 360 95%
    The Daily Mirror 5/5


    German Magazines:
    Consol Plus 91%
    Maniac 90%
    360-Live 90% Reader Review: 88%
    Play³ 90%
    Consol.AT 91%
    Games TM 9/10
    PS3M 9/10

    French Mags:
    Jeux Vidéo 19/20 -> 95%
    OPM 19/20 -> 95%
    OXM 19/20 -> 95%
    PS3M 19/20 -> 95%


    Other Countries:
    Pelaaja (Finland) 10/10
    Gamereactor 9/10
    Veronica magazine 5/5 -> 100%
    Official Playstation Magazine Benelux 8,1/10


    Online Reviews:
    Gametrailers.com 9/10
    IGN 9,3/10
    1up.com A- -> 9,3/10
    Eurogamer 9/10
    teamxbox 9,1/10
    play.tm 9,4/10
    NZGamer 9/10
    Gamesradar 9/10
    CVG 9,2/10
    g4tv 4/5
    Nowgamer 9.0/10(360)/8.5/10(PS3)
    gamepro 4/5
    AusGamers 9,5/10
    Spong 9,2/10
    TVG 8,0/10
    Xboxamerica 9,5/10
    IGN AU 8,7/10
    giag 9,0/10
    Garabia 9,0/10
    Gameplanet 8,5/10
    Gamedaily 9,0/10
    electronictheatre 9,2/10
    3news 4,5/5
    Gamespot 9,0/10
    Gamespy 5/5
    Cheatcodecentral 9,2/10
    wonderwallweb 9,5/10
    Telegraph 9/10
    USA Today 3,5/4 -> 8,75/10
    Digital Chumps 9,2/10
    Gane Revolution A- -> 9,3/10
    Gamer Limit 9/10
    ZTGameDomain 10/10
    4players.de 8,4/10
    Boomtown 9/10
    Gaming Age A -> 100%
    Empire Online 4/5
    Game Observer 9/10
    Action Trip 9,2/10
    Resolution Magazine 93/100
    The Sun (newspaper) 5/5
    Stick Skills 9,2/10
    Chicago Tribune 3,5/4
    Destructoid 8/10
    Incgamers 9,3/10
    Green Pixels 4/5
    MSN UK 4/5
    Xbox Addict 9,3/10
    Analoglyphe 9,5/10
    Game Hub 10/10
    Independent 5/5
    MS Xbox World 8,5/10
    Electric Pig 4/5
    Colony of Gamers 5/5
    The Gaming Site 9/10
    The Big Bat 5/5
    End Sights 9/10
    CS Nation 9,5/10
    Geek Syndicate 5/5
    Game Heros 9/10
    The Start Screen 9/10
    Den of Geek 5/5
    Worth Playing 9,5/10
    Gamernode 9/10
    Cinemablend 4,5/5
    Gotham Knight's online 5/5
    Gamereactor 9/10
    Game Pad 8,5/10
    Talking about Games A+ -> 9,5/100
    Wired 9/10
    Giant Bomb 5/5
    Joystick Division 4/5
    The Sixth Axis 9/10
    Cheat Happens 9/10
    Digital Spy 4/5
    Perez Start 9,5/10

    42 New Reviews, calculating scores later



    Average Rating of print media, based on 23 Reviews: 93,675/100
    Average Rating of online reviews, based on 34 Reviews: 90,368/100
    Average score out of 57 Reviews: 91,702/100


    If i missed anything PLEASE tell me - I try to find sources on every review so links would help


    Thanks to:
    door_noob
    CapedCrusader1495
    EnsanguinedWalls
    Grandi
    mrbatar
    darrinwright
    Tim Drake
    Batz-R-Us
    hlhbk
    Rocksteady (infos and for developing)

    Update: Removed 360/PS3/PC Tags, all versions received the same rating.

  2. #2
    I'll be putting up the Australian OXM review on Friday
    My Batman: Gotham City Fan Fic (A sequel to Batman: Arkham Asylum):
    http://forums.eidosgames.com/showthr...=1#post1168741

  3. #3
    Originally Posted by CapedCrusader1495
    I'll be putting up the Australian OXM review on Friday
    nice, Ryuuie may also puts those review in the FAQ-Thread

  4. #4
    Originally Posted by Termix
    nice, Ryuuie may also puts those review in the FAQ-Thread
    No problemo! As long as I get my credit then I'm happy
    My Batman: Gotham City Fan Fic (A sequel to Batman: Arkham Asylum):
    http://forums.eidosgames.com/showthr...=1#post1168741

  5. #5
    Originally Posted by GibsonSGBat
    official plastation mag gave arkham 9/10 wouldnt it be better to put 9/10 instead of 90%

    yea changed that, ty

  6. #6
    Yeah, good job! I think its great to have a central hub/portal to all the reviews!

    This thread should be stickied.
    My Batman: Gotham City Fan Fic (A sequel to Batman: Arkham Asylum):
    http://forums.eidosgames.com/showthr...=1#post1168741

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Posts
    2,400
    Cool thread

    I might just sticky this one, keep 'em coming dudes.
    "......It reminds me of Beethoven..... can you hear it?"

  8. #8
    Originally Posted by Keir
    Cool thread

    I might just sticky this one, keep 'em coming dudes.
    Thanks for stickying it Keir!
    My Batman: Gotham City Fan Fic (A sequel to Batman: Arkham Asylum):
    http://forums.eidosgames.com/showthr...=1#post1168741

  9. #9
    Image of 360-Live-Score added
    Brief Translation:
    (box on top) Reader Review:
    Second opinion:
    Overall I think the combination of partly logical puzzles, Stealth-Mode stuff and Beat-em-Up elements is great. A Top-Title, a Must-Buy this year. 8.8/10

    Main box:
    Graphics: Harmonious Look, convincing chracter design, everything runs smooth. 9/10
    Sound: Cineastic music, (?), very good synchronisation 8/10
    Gameplay: Varied, responsive, manageable, beginner friendly 8/10
    Final verdict: Without the license it would be an extraordinary Action-Adventure. But with those characters? Truly magnificent.

  10. #10
    Awesome! I'll be adding a link to this thread in the FAQ and give ya credit.

    Really nice idea!

  11. #11
    Battlestations: Midway Lieutenant Commander
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    5,513
    How can reader review be 88% when the game isn't even out yet?

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Apr 1998
    Location
    Blackfriars
    Posts
    3,885
    Originally Posted by chip5541
    How can reader review be 88% when the game isn't even out yet?
    was thinking that. shows how little you should read into reader reviews sometimes..
    www.imdb.me/jasonwalker <-thas me hehe
    Twitter: @jaywalker2309
    - My opinion is my own and not that of the company.

  13. #13
    Great thread! At the end, this is the most important thread in the forum. And Wow, no review have been under 90 O.O

  14. #14
    Originally Posted by jaycw2309
    was thinking that. shows how little you should read into reader reviews sometimes..
    I think Reader Reviews are a good idea on paper, but there are always those that spoil it by spamming 1's and 10's.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Apr 1998
    Location
    Blackfriars
    Posts
    3,885
    Originally Posted by Old_BenKenobi
    I think Reader Reviews are a good idea on paper, but there are always those that spoil it by spamming 1's and 10's.
    precisely..too open to abuse from people who've probably never owned or intend to own, but feel its their duty to bash if the feeling takes them (oh and over praise even tho not owning etc)
    www.imdb.me/jasonwalker <-thas me hehe
    Twitter: @jaywalker2309
    - My opinion is my own and not that of the company.

  16. #16
    Also, lots of people think in binary when it comes to games. It's either a 10 or a 1. They don't see a point to clicking "7" because it won't make as much of a difference to the score. To them, it's not about the consensus, it's about getting the Reader Review score as close to yours as possible.

  17. #17
    Originally Posted by chip5541
    How can reader review be 88% when the game isn't even out yet?

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    3,545
    The french magazine gave it a 19/20, I'll find the link in a moment.

    Edit here you go - http://img36.imageshack.us/img36/3310/p1020566d.jpg

  19. #19
    Join Date
    Apr 1998
    Location
    Blackfriars
    Posts
    3,885
    95% sweeeet
    www.imdb.me/jasonwalker <-thas me hehe
    Twitter: @jaywalker2309
    - My opinion is my own and not that of the company.

  20. #20
    Didn't know there was this many reviews for it already.

    Nice to know so far it's getting top scores.
    "Destruction and Terror continue, as the hulking, God-less Child-Beast carves a bloody swath through our helpless city...."

  21. #21
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    23
    Damn all the people who can play the game before us XD oh well, good scores.

    I still can't wait for this game and it will be my fav for a long time ^^

  22. #22
    Originally Posted by chip5541
    How can reader review be 88% when the game isn't even out yet?
    You could register in the german forum for this test, because so many people wanted to play it, they gave one reader the opportunity to test it 2 days

    Lol if that wasn't intented by Eidos :X

  23. #23
    Originally Posted by door noob
    The french magazine gave it a 19/20, I'll find the link in a moment.

    Edit here you go - http://img36.imageshack.us/img36/3310/p1020566d.jpg
    ty forgot about that

  24. #24
    Added: Picture of Maniac-Score which says:
    -Challenge-Mode enhances content
    -PS3-Owners can download Joker levels
    -PS3 vs. 360: The Sony version installs 1,2GB, looks a bit sharper and offers less shining colors


    Fazit: (conclusion)
    Finally a Batman-game how it's suppossed to be. Countless gadgets, dark atmosphere and perfect playability.

  25. #25
    Hey man, there is a possibility that my OXM review MAY be up earlier than expected But just maybe, we'll have to wait and see
    My Batman: Gotham City Fan Fic (A sequel to Batman: Arkham Asylum):
    http://forums.eidosgames.com/showthr...=1#post1168741

Page 1 of 13 1234511 ... Last